The Threats of a Government Apparatchik AKA Housing Authority Gone Wild – Just What Power Does East Providence Housing Authority Attorney Louise Marcus Possess

Views: 143

 

 

With the word’s lawsuit, eviction and criminal being bandied about like leftover Halloween Candy Corn, I thought it important to perform some tertiary analysis of the current legal environment surrounding Pantry Gate … A term invented by myself to somehow describe the madness that has descended upon what was a wonderful act of kindness …. A Community simply donating food for folks who could use a gentle hand up.

As folks probably can tell, I, Pat Ford, am no legal expert. This despite many years of watching Law & Order, and movies like The Big Short, and of course, Paul Newman’s masterpiece, The Verdict. I am literally not an expert yet play one on the radio. For many years I have maintained one fundamental truth about The Law. There are 3 areas: What we, the great unwashed think The Law states. What the Law should state. And what The Law actually says.

With that in mind, I preyed upon a real estate attorney to give some thought about the chaos currently in play in East Providence. He provided me with this guidance. I have not paid for this analysis. Lawyers will probably, at some level, have their day in Court. And no, this is not the work of some graduate of the Facebook School of Law. This analysis, while voluminous, is general in nature. And does not pretend to be the precursor to a Court Action.

 

Analysis

 

HUD regulations promote and protect a resident-led, non-cash food drive because federal housing law treats tenant participation as part of creating and maintaining a suitable living environment in HUD-assisted housing. Congress expressly recognized the importance and benefits of tenant cooperation and participation in multifamily housing projects, including participation that contributes to good physical condition, maintenance, security, energy
efficiency, and control of operating costs. [1] Congress also directed HUD to assure that project owners do not impede the reasonable efforts of resident tenant organizations to represent their members or the reasonable efforts of tenants to organize. [2] In covered HUD-assisted multifamily housing, the implementing regulation gives tenants the right to establish and operate a tenant organization for the purpose of addressing issues related to their living environment, including the terms and conditions of tenancy and activities related to housing and community development. [3] A resident-organized food drive for fellow tenants is
not identified by name in the regulation, but the facts that no cash was collected and only nonperishable canned food was collected make the activity much closer to resident mutual aid and community support than to commercial activity or outside fundraising. [3] The best
characterization is therefore that the food drive is a reasonable tenant-organization or resident welfare activity related to the residents’ living environment and community development, subject only to neutral health, safety, sanitation, and common-area rules.

[3] HUD regulations protect the practical steps residents need to take to organize that activity. Owners and management agents of covered multifamily projects must allow tenants and tenant organizers to distribute leaflets in lobby areas, place leaflets at or under tenants’ doors, distribute
leaflets in common areas, initiate contact with tenants, conduct door-to-door surveys to ascertain interest in tenant organizations and offer information about them, post information on bulletin boards, assist tenants to participate in tenant-organization activities, and convene regularly scheduled on-site tenant-organization meetings independent of management representatives.

[4] Owners and agents also must allow other reasonable activities related to establishing or operating a tenant organization and may not require prior permission before tenants engage in those protected activities.

[5] HUD’s enforcement regulation gives these organizing protections practical force. Owners, agents, and principals who violate Part 245, Subpart B in a way that interferes with tenants’ organizational and participatory rights may be subject to HUD sanctions, including debarment,
suspension, and a limited denial of participation.

[6] HUD’s tenant-participation rulemaking also states that the rule implements the statutory requirement that owners not impede reasonable
tenant organizing efforts, and HUD identified eviction threats, withholding entitlements, and other penalties for organizing or asserting rights as examples of impediments that commenters urged HUD to treat as violations.

[7] [8]
For public housing, HUD regulations independently protect resident participation. HUD policy promotes resident participation and active resident involvement in all aspects of a housing authority’s mission and operation, and residents have the right to organize and elect a resident
council to represent their interests.

[9] Public housing residents also receive statutory and regulatory process protections if a PHA threatens housing loss, because 42 U.S.C. § 1437d(k)
requires an administrative grievance procedure with notice of the specific grounds for proposed adverse action, an impartial hearing upon timely request, access to relevant records and regulations, representation, the right to question witnesses and present statements, and a written
decision.

[10] HUD’s public-housing grievance regulations define a grievance as any dispute about PHA action or inaction under the tenant’s lease or PHA regulations that adversely affects the tenant’s rights, duties, welfare, or status.

[11] A staff threat that a resident may lose housing for organizing or participating in the food drive would be particularly vulnerable if it was not tied to a specific lease provision, written rule, health or safety code, or documented disturbance. Public housing leases may be terminated only for serious or repeated lease violations or other good cause, and the required public-housing lease provisions require written termination notice stating specific grounds and informing the
tenant of the right to reply, examine relevant PHA documents, and request a grievance hearing when available.

[12] [13] The tenancy generally may not terminate before the time to request a grievance hearing has expired and, if a hearing is timely requested, before the grievance process has been completed.

[14] A PHA also may not proceed with eviction if it fails to make directly relevant documents available for examination upon the tenant’s request.

[15] For project-based Section 8 and other covered subsidized projects, the federal good-cause and notice framework also cuts against any threat of housing loss based merely on resident organizing. Under 12 U.S.C. § 1715z-1b, HUD-approved leases must provide that tenants may not be evicted without good cause or without adequate notice of the reasons and must not contain unreasonable terms and conditions.

[16] Under 42 U.S.C. § 1437f(d)(1)(B), during the lease term an owner may not terminate a Section 8 tenancy except for serious or repeated lease violations,
violation of applicable law, or other good cause, and any termination must be preceded by written notice specifying the grounds.

[17] [18] For tenant-based voucher tenancies, 42 U.S.C. §1437f(o)(7) similarly requires that termination during the lease term be limited to serious or
repeated lease violations, violation of applicable law, or other good cause, with written notice specifying the grounds.

[19] HUD’s Part 247 eviction regulations provide additional protections for certain subsidized and HUD-owned multifamily projects. A landlord may not terminate a tenancy in a covered subsidized project except for material noncompliance, material failure to carry out obligations under state landlord-tenant law, specified criminal activity or alcohol abuse, or other good cause.

[20] A termination notice must state the reasons for termination with enough specificity to allow the tenant to prepare a defense, must advise that enforcement can occur only through judicial action if the tenant remains, and failure to object to the notice does not waive the tenant’s right to contest the landlord’s action in court.

[21] [22] The landlord may evict only by judicial action under state or local law and Part 247, and in court the landlord generally must rely on grounds
stated in the termination notice.

[23] [24] If the property is HOME-assisted, federal law and regulations provide another express anti retaliation framework. HOME’s authorizing statute prohibits termination or nonrenewal except for serious or repeated lease violations, violation of applicable law, or other good cause, and
generally requires at least 30 days’ written notice specifying the grounds.

[25] The HOME regulation states that tenants must have reasonable access to and use of common areas and must be able to organize, create tenant associations, convene meetings, distribute literature, and post information. [26] It also prohibits unreasonable interference with the tenant’s safety or peaceful
enjoyment of the unit or common areas and prohibits retaliation for taking action allowable under the lease and applicable law.

[27] Conduct evidencing retaliation includes attempting to recover possession in a manner inconsistent with the regulation, decreasing services, increasing
obligations outside the regulation, harassing the household or lawful guests, refusing to honor the lease, and other actions taken for the purpose of causing the housing to become vacant.

[28] Case law supports treating threats or eviction proceedings aimed at tenant organizing as unlawful retaliation, especially where the housing provider is a public housing authority or the facts establish state action. In Walton v. Darby Town Houses, Inc., the court found that management told a tenant’s wife that the family would be evicted if the tenant did not stop organizing tenants and later caused a landlord-tenant complaint to be filed in retaliation for tenant organizing and
complaints to local and HUD officials.

[29] [30] [31] The court held that the tenant’s association and petitioning activity were protected by the First Amendment and that the retaliatory eviction
violated the tenants’ First and Fourteenth Amendment rights in a Section 1983 action.

[32] [33] Belvoir Cliffs Apartments, Ltd. v. Bembry reached a similar result in a Section 8 substantial rehabilitation project. The court held that tenant association and organizing activities are embraced by the First Amendment and that the landlord’s attempt to evict the tenant in retaliation for tenant-organization activity was illegal.

[34] Carrera v. Yepez likewise framed the relevant question as whether eviction proceedings, denial of grievance procedures, or removal of
resident-council officers motivated by retaliation for First Amendment activity violated public housing tenants’ constitutional rights. [35] Carrera emphasized that a public-housing tenant’s continued occupancy cannot be conditioned on the tenant’s foregoing constitutional rights.

[36] The no-cash, nonperishable-food facts are also important because they undercut the most likely management justifications. In Kolio v. Hawaii Public Housing Authority, a public-housing authority evicted a tenant-association president after he pleaded guilty to theft of association funds, but the Hawaii Supreme Court reversed because the authority failed to show that the conduct threatened the health, safety, or peaceful enjoyment of the premises as required by the
HUD-based lease language.

[37] [38] [39] [40] A resident who merely collected nonperishable canned food, without collecting cash, presents a much weaker basis for any housing-loss threat
than the facts in Kolio, and staff would still need to identify a lease violation or concrete health, safety, sanitation, or peaceful-enjoyment problem rather than relying on generalized disapproval of resident organizing.

[41] There are several potential protections and forms of relief. The first and most immediate step is
to demand written clarification of the alleged rule violation and preservation of the resident’s
right to organize. In a covered multifamily project, the resident can cite 12 U.S.C. § 1715z1b(b)(4), 24 C.F.R. §§ 245.100 and 245.115, and 24 C.F.R. § 245.135, and can ask management to retract any threat that organizing or participation in a no-cash canned-food drive could result
in loss of housing.

[42] The second step is to use the applicable administrative process. In public housing, the tenant should present a grievance orally or in writing at

the PHA office or project management office, which triggers an informal settlement process and a written summary identifying the participants,
dates, proposed disposition, reasons, and procedures for obtaining a hearing if the tenant is dissatisfied.

[43] If a hearing is required, the tenant has the right to examine relevant PHA documents, be represented by counsel or another chosen representative, request a private hearing, present evidence and arguments, challenge PHA evidence, confront and cross-examine witnesses, and receive a decision based only on the facts presented at the hearing.

[44] [45] The third step is to treat any termination notice or eviction as defective unless it satisfies the applicable federal notice, good-cause, and judicial-process rules. Public housing tenants can rely on 42 U.S.C. § 1437d(k) and (l), 24 C.F.R. §§ 966.4, 966.51, 966.53, 966.54, and 966.56,
including the right to specific grounds, access to relevant documents, a grievance hearing where
required, and due process before eviction. [46] [47] [48] Tenants in covered subsidized multifamily projects can rely on 12 U.S.C. § 1715z-1b, 24 C.F.R. Part 247, and any program specific lease addendum to require good cause, adequate notice, and judicial process.

[49] The fourth step is to seek HUD enforcement. For covered multifamily projects, 24 C.F.R. § 245.135 authorizes HUD sanctions against owners, agents, principals, and affiliates who interfere with tenants’ organizational and participatory rights, including debarment, suspension, and limited denial of participation.

[50] [51] [52] HUD may also use other administrative tools in related civil-rights matters, including referral to the Attorney General, proceedings leading to
debarment or other administrative sanctions, and referrals to other federal, state, or local enforcement agencies when nondiscrimination obligations are implicated.

[53] The fifth step is litigation if the threat ripens into a formal adverse action or if immediate injunctive relief is needed. Courts have granted or recognized injunctive and declaratory relief in subsidized housing cases where tenants alleged unlawful eviction procedures or retaliation for protected tenant organizing.

[54] [55] [56] Section 1983 may be available where the defendant acts under color of state law and the resident asserts a federal constitutional right or a sufficiently
specific federal statutory right.

[57] Wright v. City of Roanoke held that nothing in the Housing Act or Brooke Amendment foreclosed Section 1983 enforcement of sufficiently specific tenant
rights, and the Court emphasized that a state-court remedy is not a reason to bar Section 1983.

[58] Samuels v. District of Columbia held that public housing tenants stated a valid Section 1983 claim based on alleged failure to provide the grievance procedures required by federal housing law and HUD regulations.

[59] There are limits to the federal private-enforcement theory, so the claim should be pleaded carefully. Some authority rejects a direct implied private right of action under HUD tenant organization regulations or 12 U.S.C. § 1715z-1b against private entities, especially where the claim depends only on regulations and no state action is shown.

[60] [61] [62] [63] For that reason, the strongest litigation posture is to plead any available constitutional retaliation claim,
Section 1983 claim against a public actor or state actor, state or local retaliatory-eviction claim, lease and regulatory defenses, and HUD administrative enforcement, rather than relying only on an implied private right under Part 245.

[56] [64] Fair Housing Act retaliation may be available if the facts connect the threat to a protected fair housing right or protected-class-based advocacy. Section 3617 makes it unlawful to coerce, intimidate, threaten, or interfere with a person’s exercise or enjoyment of rights protected by
specified Fair Housing Act provisions, or because the person aided or encouraged another person’s exercise or enjoyment of those rights.

[65] HUD’s regulation likewise prohibits threatening or interfering with persons in their enjoyment of a dwelling because of protected class status, intimidating or threatening a person for activities designed to make others aware of Fair Housing Act rights, and retaliating against a person for making a complaint or reporting a
discriminatory housing practice.

[66] [67] [68] If that nexus exists, an aggrieved person may file a HUD complaint and may also bring a civil action seeking actual and punitive damages,
temporary or permanent injunctive relief, other appropriate orders, and, in the court’s discretion, attorney’s fees and costs.

[69] Accordingly, the requested response can state that HUD’s statutory and regulatory framework affirmatively protects resident organizing and prohibits housing staff from converting protected resident outreach into a ground for housing loss.

[70] On the stated facts, the resident organized a no-cash canned-food drive for fellow tenants, which is best treated as resident mutual aid and
tenant organizing rather than a lease violation. [3] A threat that participation could result in loss of housing should be challenged immediately in writing, reported through the applicable HUD or PHA channel, preserved as evidence of interference or retaliation, and asserted as a defense or
affirmative claim if any termination notice or eviction follows. [71] [72] [73

Comments: 0

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *